You might have often heard terminologies such as:
(Very simple definition given)
1. Monotheism= One God exists denying existence of polytheistic environment
2. Polytheism= Many gods exist
3. Pantheism= God is all, All is God,
4. Deism= God exists but doesn't interact with creation
5. Animism= Worship of Nature
6. Panentheism= Existence of universe is within God etc.
But have you ever heard the term Henotheism?
Let me simply illustrate: we are in a Hindu environment right? So, there are particular Hindu friends or neighborhood who might say something like- I worship Shiva in particular but do not reject pantheon of Hindu deities. Now, that's what is called Henotheism (Although, learnt Hindus usually deny this for sure!).
But, how is henotheism different from monotheism?
|
Henotheism |
Monotheism |
1 |
The word comes from the Greek ‘heis’ which means one and
‘theos’ which means God. This is not to be confused with monotheism which is
the belief that there is only one God in all existence.[1] |
The word monotheism comes from the Greek μόνος (monos) meaning
"single" and θεός (theos) meaning "god".[2] |
2 |
In both principle and fact. |
|
3 |
Term coined by Max Muller[5],[6] who introduced it
as a transitional stage from polytheism to monotheism.[7],[8] |
According to the hypothesis, monotheism was first
attempted by the Egyptian pharaoh Akhenaten (Amenhotep IV), who attempted to
substitute for the previously held polytheism the exclusive worship of Aten.[9] The English term was first used by Henry More (1614–1687).[10] |
4 |
devotion to a single primary god while accepting the
existence or possible existence of other deities. It can also be the gods form a hierarchy with a chief god.[11] |
Belief in existence of only one God or oneness of God. |
5 |
Related terms are monolatrism and kathenotheism[12], which are typically
understood as sub-types of henotheism.[13] |
There is, however, a wide range of positions between
exclusive monotheism at one extreme and unlimited polytheism at the other.[14] Between the extremes of
exclusive monotheism and unlimited polytheism are the middle positions of
inclusive monotheism and henotheism. |
6 |
Henotheism is similar but less exclusive than monolatry
because a monolator worships only one god, while the henotheist may worship
any within the pantheon, depending on circumstances.[15] |
Exclusive monotheism: only one god exists; other gods
either simply do not exist at all or, at most, are false gods or demons—i.e.,
beings that are acknowledged to exist but that cannot be compared in power or
any other way with the one and only true God. Inclusive monotheism: accepts the existence of a great
number of gods but holds that all gods are essentially one and the same, so
that it makes little or no difference under which name or according to which
rite a god or goddess is invoked.[16] |
7 |
Critics insists, instead of taking the trouble of coining
the word ‘henotheism’, Max Muller could have simply said that the gods are
regarded as mere manifestation of the Supreme God so that when any god was
praised he was not praised in his individual capacity, but merely as the
manifestation of the Supreme God.[17] |
Critics insists, monotheism runs into difficulties in
trying to answer the question concerning the origin of evil in a universe
under the government of one god.[18] |
8 |
This system of theism has no objection over existence of
other gods but personally get attached or associate to one particular God. It
is distinct from its sub-category Kathenotheism as this holds to one
particular god at one time that might alter in life according to demand and
situations or so. It is also distinct from Monolatrism in which only one
particular god is worthy of worship in crowd of many gods.[19] It may have social, geographical or individual preference
basis.[20] |
In general, Monotheism excludes the existence and worship
of other deities, powers or gods. |
9 |
It exists in a polytheistic environment.[21] |
It exists outside a polytheistic environment generally. |
10 |
Hinduism can be one best example for its practice in general
daily life. Also, the Bible reports its practice in O.T. periods (E.g. Isaiah
37, 2 Kings 5).[22] |
Religions like Judaism, Christianity and Islam |
Peer Reviewed
by: Parv Pravakar and Nitish Singh
[1] https://carm.org/dictionary/henotheism-2/,
9.04 pm, 11/28/2021
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monotheism#:~:text=16%20External%20links-,Etymology,More%20(1614–1687).,
9.15 pm, 11/28/2021
[3] https://www2.nau.edu/~gaud/bio301/content/heno.htm,
1:31 pm, 11/28/2021
[4] https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/israel/henotheism.htm,
1:43 pm, 11/28/2021
[6] Klaus
K. Klostermaier, A Survey of Hinduism. State University of New York Press.
2007. Pg. 120/720 (pdf)
[7]
Sharma, Chandradhar. Critical Survey of Indian Philosophy. Barnes & Noble,
Inc. 1962. Pg. 13/415 (pdf)
[8]
Corduan. Neighboring Faiths. Pg. 37
[9]
Corduan, Winfried. Neighboring Faiths. Pg. 38
[10] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monotheism#:~:text=16%20External%20links-,Etymology,More%20(1614–1687).,
11/28/2021
[11]
Geisler. Christian Apologetics.
[12] an extension of "henotheism", from (kath' hena theon)
—"one god at a time"
[14] https://www.britannica.com/topic/monotheism/The-spectrum-of-views-monotheisms-and-quasi-monotheisms,
9.20 pm, 11/28/2021
[16] https://www.britannica.com/topic/monotheism/The-spectrum-of-views-monotheisms-and-quasi-monotheisms,
9.28 pm, 11/28/2021
[17]
Critical Survey of Indian Philosophy. Pg. 14/415
[18] https://www.britannica.com/topic/monotheism,
9.31 pm, 11/28/2021
[19] https://youtu.be/gK4Fa--SPNY, 9.02 pm,
11/28/2021
[20]
Neighboring Faiths. Pg. 37
[21]
Geisler. Christian Apologetics 2nd Edition. Baker. 2013. Pg. 192/423
pdf
[22]
Neighboring Faiths. Pg. 37
0 Comments